Thoughts01 / 02

Yes, I Judge Books by Their Covers

Date
21.11.26
Entry
01 / 02
Reading
3 min
Words
654

Being a graphic designer is not something I can switch off. My brain is basically a design critic that never takes a day off. I can't just walk outside and unsee things. Bad typography. Pixelated prints. Weird letter spacing on a shop sign. Papyrus (holy sh*t). It's everywhere.

And I'm not the only one. In 2017, Saturday Night Live made a whole sketch about this. Ryan Gosling plays a man who can't sleep because Avatar, one of the biggest movies ever, used Papyrus for its logo. Half the design world watched it and thought: finally, someone gets me. In 2024, there was even a sequel. The trauma is real.

There's a word for this, by the way. The French call it déformation professionnelle: when your job changes the way you see the world. In German, we'd just say Berufskrankheit. Editors find typos in birthday cards. Musicians hear the one guitar string that's slightly out of tune. I used to work as a photographer with a lot of rock and metal bands, so trust me, I've seen that face. The whole crowd is screaming, and the band still hears it. And designers? We see the logo on the new shop around the corner and just know: Shutterstock, 20 dollars. No judgment. Okay, maybe a little.

But is it really because of my job? Or did all those years of design just train my eye? Well, I think I was born with it. End of discussion.

People keep telling me that I always go for expensive things. Apple, for example. Not Dolce & Gabbana. I'm not that kind of expensive. But my answer is simple: they're pretty. Not because they cost a lot, but because someone clearly thought about every little detail. The products are pretty. The websites are pretty. Even the packaging is pretty. And all of that inspires me. My life is basically one big moodboard.

Funny thing is, it's not only designers. Most people just don't say it out loud. Back in 1995, two researchers at Hitachi in Japan showed people 26 different versions of an ATM screen. Just pictures, nobody actually used them. The result: the prettier the screen looked, the easier people thought it would be to use. Today, this is called the aesthetic-usability effect. Pretty things simply feel like they work better.

And it happens fast. A study from Canada found that people decide if they like the look of a website in about 50 milliseconds. That's faster than a blink. And in a big Stanford study, people explained why they trusted a website or not. Almost half of their comments were about how the site looked. The professor who led it summed it up like this: “To look good is to be good.” Sad but true, as Metallica would say.

So yes, I judge books by their covers. Just like everyone else. When I go to a café, I want it to look good. Good design always catches my eye. I study the menu instead of deciding what to order. And before I buy anything online, I spend way too much time looking at how the website is built. Sometimes I forget what I wanted to buy. Guilty.

Some people might call me superficial. In German: oberflächlich, which somehow sounds even harsher. And you know what? Yes, I am. If noticing and caring about how things look makes me superficial, then so be it.

And honestly, things are allowed to just be pretty. Not everything needs a deeper meaning. But as a designer, I also know that good design usually does a little more than look nice. A good menu helps you order. A clear sign helps you find your way. A good website can make a business feel more trustworthy.

I guess that's what happens when design is more than just your job. You start seeing it everywhere. Whether you want to or not.

Especially when it's Papyrus.